A New Year wish - independence for the judiciary

comments     Choo Sing Chye     Published     Updated

Is it too encumbering for the rakyat to ask for a judiciary that is not only independent, but also seen as such?


azlan The three pillars of good government, the Legislature, the Executive and the Judiciary must be separated. The legislature legislates laws, the executive executes them, and the judiciary checks its implementation.

But in a Westminster parliamentary system, we shouldn’t put too high a hope because the prime minister is the head of the Legislature and at the same time, heads the cabinet which is the Executive. These two entities are seamlessly interchangeable.

In Britain, the separation of powers rest squarely on the Judiciary.  

“In 1984, Clive Ponting, a senior civil servant in the Naval Affairs office after the Falklands War, was charged for leaking information to a Labour Member of Parliament. Ponting’s bosses at the Defence ministry had been systematically lying to the parliamentary committee investigating the sinking of the cruiser General Belgrano.

“Poning believed that when Prime Minister Thatcher ordered the attack on the Argentine cruiser, it was already leaving the war zone. There were 368 Argentine lives lost in the sinking, and many Britons were killed in reprisal.  

“Feeling that, two years later, a cover-up was still in effect, Ponting decided he owed a higher allegiance to truth and to Parliament than to his bureaucratic superiors.

“Arrested and tried by the government, Ponting was eventually acquitted in a much-publicised trial at the Old Bailey, by a jury of 12 ordinary men and women who, like their fellow citizens, saw no harm in a civil servant insisting on honesty in government.” (1)

In Malaysia, the BN leaders had reduced the parliament into a rubber stamp. And with the sacking of Salleh Abbas, had further provided BN leaders with near-absolute judicial power. Now they can change and interpret laws as they like.  

Just like in a quasi-democracy, the Malaysian Judiciary is seen as another extension of the Executive.

Should we, the rakyat, be contented with the state of affairs that we are in now?

While our neighbours’ democratic spaces are expanding, Malaysia’s is shrinking. Even Burma has been taking baby-steps towards the direction of democracy.

Apparently, there is no reason whatsoever for the BN leaders to lead our country into the abyss of dictatorship. Only you can stop this trend through the ballot box in the 13th general election.

A reminder: “Whereas animals live by instinct and therefore do what they do directly, we can decide between alternatives, and this choice is possible because we can reflect on how we are going to act.” - Philosophy in the Mass Society , by George Grant.

So don't look the other way, because the choice is yours.


(1) Patrick Watson & Benjamin Barber. The Struggle For Democracy , Toronto: 1988


Review:  The book, The Struggle for Democracy , touches on many aspects of democracy and it gives us a myriad of insightful events which touches the very cord of this subject. This book is a good read, especially for politicians.

Keep Malaysiakini independent!

Malaysiakini will be 18 this year. That we’ve survived this long is because of you.

Your support matters. A lot. Especially those who pay RM150 annually, RM288 biennially or RM388 triennially to keep Malaysiakini independent from government/opposition influence and corporate interests. Advertising alone will not keep Malaysiakini afloat.

Together, we’ve gone far. We’ve covered three prime ministers, four general elections, five Bersih rallies, and countless scandals. But the journey continues.

Help us deliver news and views that matter to Malaysians. Help us make a difference for Malaysia.

Support Malaysiakini

news and views that matter

Sign In