We are appalled by Human Rights Commission (Suhakam) vice-chairperson Harun Hashim's statement asking the seven undergraduates - who want to be reinstated by their respective universities - to accept the 'deal' offered by the education minister, which is to apologise.

The seven students - dubbed ISA 7 - were denied the right to continue their studies following a protracted hearing of a charge of illegal assembly two years ago.

Dema, a group that promotes the acceptance and practice of human rights, condemns in the strongest possible terms the arrest of the seven students. We also deem the suspension of the students to be a flagrant violation of human rights.

Unfortunately, Harun who said that "they (ISA 7) should not be stubborn and should just apologise", does not appear to really understand the significance of human rights.

Under Article 10(1)(b) of the Federal Constitution, all citizens have the right to assemble peaceably. This is also guaranteed under Article 20(1) of Universal Declaration of Human Rights. Obviously, the statement of the Suhakam vice-chairperson is not based on basic human rights values and principles.

Dema is aware that this could be Harun's personal stand as Suhakam has not made its views known. But the implications of Harun's statements are far-reaching to say the least. His statement suggests the following:

1) The arrest of the ISA 7 is acceptable.

2) The suspension of ISA 7 is appropriate.

3) The ISA 7 has done something wrong and there is a need for them to apologise.

4) The Universities and University Colleges Act is a lawful act.

There should be no compromise when dealing with violation of basic human rights. We therefore call upon Suhakam to remain true and honest to its statutory duties as enumerated under the Human Rights Commission of Malaysia Act 1999.

Last but not least, we urge Suhakam to apologise publicly for releasing such a reckless and irresponsible statement.

Chang Lih Kang

Malaysia Youth and Students Democratic Movement (Dema)