Merdeka: Aug 31 or Sept 16?
John Lee Sep 7, 05 12:24pm
I refer to WK's letter on the correct date of Malaysia's independence. While it is true that only Malaya achieved independence on Aug 31, 1957, I find it pedantic to argue over the correct dating of independence when there are far bigger issues facing the nation.

Malaya was founded as a federation. On September 16, the federation included Sabah, Sarawak and Singapore. To reflect the change of its composition, its name was changed to Malaysia.

Other countries that operate on a federal basis, like the United States of America, count their date of independence as the date their federation was founded, regardless of when additional states were added. I wouldn't be surprised if Malaysia operates on a similar basis.

After all, the federation did not cease to exist and suddenly declare independence again on September 16. It merely added three new states and changed its name.

Even presuming that it is correct to use September 16 as the date of Malaysia's independence, is anything achieved by doing so? I believe that there are many more fundamental problems Malaysia must deal with, and the least of them is our date of independence.

That roughly half the country is not as Malaysian as the other half is one of many serious problems facing the country. The question of when we officially became independent simply pales in comparison.

SMS News Alerts
Maxis users
- Type "BUY MKINI" and send to "26000" (RM 5.00 per month)
- Type "BUY WMKINI" and send to "26000" (RM 1.50 per week)
Umobile users
- Type "ON NW MKINIENG" and send to "28118" (RM 5.00 per month)
Digi users
- Type "ON MKINI" and send to "2000" (RM 5.00 per month)
Share your views

Got a short comment or two on our reports/articles? Send it over to Vox Populi, a free forum for readers to air their views on Malaysiakini’s news reports, columns, opinions, letters and analyses. Please keep your comments brief and provide a pseudonym if you so wish. Vox Populi differs from Letters to the Editor in that it caters specifically for brief, to the point comments. Do please indicate which report/article you are referring to. Send your Vox Populi comments to: editor@malaysiakini.com

For Maxis, UMobile, Digi users, get sms newsalerts
Download Mobilekini to get the full story on your phone
Subscribe to Daily news digest
Email:
Join 2800+ friends at the Malaysiakini Group Facebook
Follow Malaysiakini's newsfeed on Twitter
Diy Day Banner

Advertise here ( RM15/day )

Advertise here ( RM15/day )

Diy Day Banner