Is Malaysia a model Islamic country which is progressive and moderate with the minimum universal standards of human rights? Current events in Malaysia over the past few months alone paint a very sad and disheartening picture for democratic and fair-minded persons:
- Rational public discussions (Article 11 forums ) disrupted by police who pander to irrational mobs who shamelessly infringe on others' democratic rights with threats and intimidations (contrast this with the police not ending prematurely the Asean meeting disrupted by the Umno Youth mob);
The list goes on. How is any one of the above compatible with human rights and democracy?
The country is heading towards a direction where the majority's interpretation of the Constitution prevails, regardless of whether it perverts the language of the Constitution.
It is sad, but it is time we all admit that most Malaysians do not fully appreciate or accept the fundamental values of democracy. We do not have the democratic culture which would sustain a true democracy.
Democracy does not only mean majority rule - it also has to go hand-in-hand with minority rights. Majority rule without minority rights is only tyranny of the majority, and no minority would be stupid enough to accept such a system.
Fundamental in the system of democracy is absolute acceptance and protection of the fundamental rights of minorities, no matter who they are - including the minority of one individual who does not wish to belong to any religion. A democracy must protect those freedoms and rights.
So, to call present day Malaysia 'democratic' is, perhaps, deceptive. When you consider that 'official religion' could mean 'Islamic state', words in the Constitution no longer carry any serious meaning.
If we continue to abuse the language of our Constitution, it would be intellectually dishonest to call Malaysia a democracy compatible with the universal standard of human rights. The recent experience of Article 11 has shown that it is meaningless - if not dangerous - to reason with people who do not fully understand and accept the true values of democracy.
Instead of championing the Constitution and the causes of human rights, perhaps the focus of our human rights activists should be in laying the groundwork - educating our children and masses on the values of democracy and minority rights, in order to build a strong and lasting cultural foundation for democracy.
Because, as we have seen recently, when such a culture is weak, even a grandly-worded Constitution is not even worth the papers it is printed on.