• SPECIAL DEBATE: In the name of Allah
  • 1175851620









  • It all began with Animah Ferrar's High time to learn about other religions.

    In her letter to Malaysiakini, she urged everyone to learn something about one another's religious beliefs and practices. It was the following paragraphs that spark off a rather curious debate in Malaysiakini:

    "While it makes eminent sense to present the (religious) teachings in the language(s) with which the target audience is most comfortable, to avoid confusion and suspicion, writers and translators should avoid using terminology exclusive to a particular religion in articles or books about another religion.

    "An example would be using 'Allah' (the Quranic name of God) in books on, say, Hinduism or Christianity, which might be construed as an attempt to mislead Muslims to believe that the book is about Islam. At this point in time, we need to be sensitive about such things."

    Following this, readers argued over the exclusivity of the use of the word 'Allah', and it led to a related issue on whether non-Muslims could use the greetings 'Assalamualaikum'.

    The following is a selection of the letters on the debate (click on 'Related Stories', see left column)

    • Being politically correct with �Assalamualaikum�
    • Muslim vs Non-Muslim: A M�sian ritual, not a debate
    • Courteous for non-Muslims to say 'Walaikumsalam'
    • Assalamualaikum, Middle Eastern-style
    • In the name of God
    • Religion did not fail people, people failed the religion
    • Bone-headed letters on Gods
    • 'Assalamualaikum� a popular greeting
    • Only one God in control of universe
    • No copyright on the term �Allah�
    • �Allah� in Arabic beyond gender
    • One man�s ceiling, another man�s floor
    • Only Allah is Allah
    • Godly terms a human rights issue
    • Greetings: Let�s just stick to �Hai� and �Oi�
    • Whatever our religion, we�re on the same team
    • Sikhs also use the word �Allah�
    • Let�s not make a fuss over greetings
    • �Allah� not proper for non-Arabic Christians
    • �Allah� widely used in many countries
    • My God...
    • Not right for other religions to use �Allah�
    • All Gods the same
    • �Abraham� a variation of �Brahma'
    • Non-Muslims too can reply to �Assalamualaikum�
    • Allah, Tuhan, Lord and God
    • Others using �Allah� will confuse Muslims
    • �Allah� is gender-neutral
    • No two Gods the same
    • First-century Arab Christians used �Allah�
    • Majority on non-Muslim Arabs use �Allah� for God
    • �Allah� not begotten nor begets
    • �God�, �Jesus� not the same thing in Christianity
    • Religion - mutually respectful dialogue needed
    • All should be allowed to use the term �Allah�
    • May the Dude bless you...
    • �Tuhan� more appropriate translation for �God�
    • Arabic term used in Indonesian bibles
    • Natural for monotheistic religions to use certain terminology
    • High time to learn about other religions
    • Being politically correct with �Assalamualaikum�