PKR vice-president Azmin Ali (Gombak) accused former minister for international trade and industry (Miti) Rafidah Aziz (Umno-Kuala Kangsar) of giving Approved Permits (AP) to family members even after it was explicitly forbidden.The committee set to deal with APs - chaired by Miti secretary-general Sidek Hassan - ruled against giving out franchise APs for 2005.