Why was Pastor Koh kidnapped?

Opinion  |  S Thayaparan
Published:  |  Modified:

Deception is a state of mind and the mind of the state (attributed to James Jesus Angleton).”

- Umberto Eco, ‘Numero zero’

Around the same time a North Korean dictator's half-brother was assassinated, a Malaysian was abducted. Now I am not implying that there is any connection but when Big News ask me to look here, I am one of those people who are more interested in looking there.

I have no idea why Raymond Koh Keng Joo was kidnapped. Indeed, at the time of writing, no form of financial motive has been discovered. Indeed, the only money that has been offered is a reward by the family for information leading to his release.

What I do know is that this is atypical for a kidnapping in Malaysia. I have no idea why the state security apparatus was slow to acknowledge this. The literature of kidnappings in Malaysia is clear-cut. Personal and financial motives are the norm, and ransom paying as the means of resolution is commonplace.

What is not normal is the manner in which he was abducted. As reported in the media, the family was told by witnesses that “one of the men was seen recording the incident while another diverted traffic. All of the kidnappers were reportedly wearing black ski masks” - that implies a certain formality to the proceedings.

There are numerous reasons why professional kidnappers would record the abduction, normally for certificate of life - popularly known as “proof of life” - evidence, but what is unusual is that there has been no ransom demands. However, in this case the recording raises other implications, which I will get to later.

What is unusual - if witnesses are to believed - is that one of the abductors was directing traffic and this implies a level of confidence that while not unusual is certainly suspicious when it comes to the victim of this particular case.

The imagery of these black masked kidnappers is an important factor in this narrative. How many times have we witness the spectacle of the state security apparatus “arresting” people - politicians, activists and dissenters - on various criminal charges while other state actors are exempt from those charges?

I am not implying anything, but to not mention something like this strikes me as disingenuous. Of course, kidnappers who operate in broad daylight will mask themselves, I am just making this observation to acknowledge what people are thinking about but are hesitant to say publicly.

While there are many security reasons why the state would make arrests in such a manner - and I would be in agreement with - the reality is that if people are suspicious of the actions of the state security apparatus, it is incumbent on the state to correct such misconceptions. So far, they have done a poor job and sadly continue to nurture the perception that the security apparatus serves the hegemon instead of the people.

Then there is the alleged “recording” of the proceedings. There is no point in not acknowledging the fact that Raymond Koh had received attention from the state on that most pernicious of allegations. When you are a Christian in Malaysia, especially if you are a pastor in charge of whichever denominational flock you shepherd, you are sometimes open to charges of proselytisation.

I have seen no cogent evidence that members of the Christian clergy are attempting to convert Malays to the Christian faith. Indeed, I wish those making such cowardly accusations would adduce evidence instead of wilfully creating a toxic atmosphere amongst followers of the Abrahamic mode.

Till this day, after the numerous raids, the banning of religious text, the vilification of Christians and the numerous other provocations in the guise of “defending” the majority’s faith, there has not been one shred of evidence that there is a concerted effort to proselytise to Muslims in this country.

Share this story


Welcome back,

Your subscription expires on

Your subscription will expire soon, kindly renew before

Your subscription is expired
  Click here to renew

You are not subscribed to any subscription package
  Click here to subscribe now

Any questions?
  Email: [email protected]
  Call: +603-777-00000