The enigma of Tan Seng Giaw

Opinion  |  Terence Netto
Published:  |  Modified:

COMMENT | So Dr Tan Seng Giaw has been dropped by the DAP as its parliamentary candidate for Kepong after eight terms on the trot as the incumbent.

He is 76 this year, an age that would have been considered old in the pre-Mahathir era but not now.

They say the test of a great writer is that after him no one can write without being aware of him.

These days much the same can be said of one's age: after what Dr Mahathir Mohamad has done and continues to do in his 10th decade in life, no one can say that someone in his 70s is old.

What more when one is dark-haired and full coiffed, lean and lithe as Seng Giaw is. Who would want to put him out to pasture, as DAP has done?

Inevitably, the question arises: Did Seng Giaw, a medical practitioner like his patron, Dr Tan Chee Khoon, live up to his billing as the protege of a man on whom the appellation 'Mr Opposition' was deservedly conferred for epitomising a brand of opposition politics considered principled and noble.

Seng Giaw was introduced into the opposition's ranks by Chee Khoon in 1978 for his parliamentary seat of Batu after a stroke in 1976 had disabled Chee Khoon.

Chee Khoon had been the Batu MP from 1964 to 1978, variously under the Labour Party, Gerakan Rakyat Malaysia (later renamed Parti Gerakan) and, finally, Pekemas, the vehicle Chee Khoon set up after Gerakan was split by Dr Lim Chong Yu's decision in the early 1970s to enlist its Penang chapter with an expanded Alliance that became the ruling Barisan Nasional.

Seng Giaw contested Batu under the Pekemas banner in the 1978 general election but lost to Dr Tan Tiong Hong of the Gerakan.

This was the era when there was a surge of medical doctors in the political arena, hitherto dominated by lawyers, ex-civil servants and people who began their working life as teachers.

After Pekemas waned following Chee Khoon's stroke, Seng Giaw did the sensible thing, which was to join DAP and then contested the Kepong ward, redrawn to subsume Batu for the 1982 general election, and won it with an ease that belied the BN juggernaut marshalled by the new-broom leadership of Mahathir and Musa Hitam.

With his fluency in Bahasa Malaysia, honed from his primary school days in his home state of Kelantan; with his background in Chinese secondary school education in Penang sans its chauvinistic hues; and with his willingness to debate the ruling BN in Parliament and public forums where he adduced arguments delivered in a style that was arresting for its blend of Malay literary norms and western rhetorical conventions, Seng Giaw was eminently watchable...

Sign in

Welcome back,

Your subscription expires on

Your subscription will expire soon, kindly renew before

Your subscription is expired
  Click here to renew

You are not subscribed to any subscription package
  Click here to subscribe now

Any questions?
  Email: [email protected]
  Call: +603-777-00000