LETTER

S'gor water crisis: Find solutions, not scapegoats

Piarapakaran S

Published
Modified 19 Jul 2012, 12:21 pm

The Association of Water and Energy Research Malaysia (Awer) urges water concessionaires, Selangor state government and Ministry of Energy, Green Technology and Water (KeTTHA) to stop misleading the public and blaming each other in childish manner.

Restructuring of national water services industry is inevitable and water concessionaires are fully aware of the strength of Water Services Industry Act 2006 (WSIA) because WSIA protects the people.

Because the Selangor state government and KeTTHA continue to lock horns, restructuring is being delayed since year 2008.

If the delay continues, the ultimate winners are the water concessionaires.

We must also not forget some irresponsible KeTTHA officers are playing along in delaying national water services industry restructuring.

These officers have blind folded the minister and cabinet in many decision making processes.

Supply and Demand Situation

The Selangor state government should stop misleading the public by issuing statements that dams are full and it always rains.

The core issue here is, supply of treated water is near equal to demand.

If you have 500 packets of nasi lemak to be sold and people want to buy 520 packets, can you satisfy their needs?

This is the simplest example to explain the current water supply issue.

Furthermore, dams are design to store raw water for specified months without rain. This is a design criterion in engineering for dams.

Raw water will be treated via water treatment plant to produce treated water.

The entire supply-demand issue is related to treated water, not raw water.

Adding a new treatment plant to a dam will jeopardise the design buffer .

For example, if a dam is designed to withstand three months of drought, increasing treatment capacity by adding a new treatment plant at the particular dam will drain it in under three months when drought happens.

When peak demand happens and reserve margin falls to the negative region, the treated water in service reservoirs will start to be used up quickly.

In a worst case scenario, when the treated water supply resumes to normal, these reservoirs might not fill up as the demand for treated water is still high.

If this escalates, it will cause water supply disruption.

For areas without these reservoirs (some industrial and residential zones), they are fully at the mercy of pressure in the distribution pipes.

This is not fiction and it is a real engineering situation.

The possibility for this to happen is high when reserve margin is very low.

Any international water firm consulted will give the same output as it's a purely engineering situation.

Non-revenue water (NRW) reduction

Reduction of NRW needs short term and long term plans.

Awer has successfully pushed the federal government to form the NRW Reduction Task Force under Suruhanjaya Perkhidmatan Air Negara (Span).

Streamlining the solution for NRW reduction is important so that recovery of investment is fast and we invest in the correct projects.

All water operators in Malaysia are facing financial constraints to reduce NRW as the capital expenditure (capex) is high.

A solution for this problem will be derived by this task force while ensuring no misuse in allocations as well as effective NRW reduction to be put in place.

Reducing NRW by 10 percent in Selangor cannot be done in one or two years time as the impact to tariff will be high.

We need to identify critical areas to get immediate savings! The situation (NRW issue) is made worse by the delay in water services industry restructuring and failure to implement WSIA model fully.

Water Rationing

Before obtaining approval from Span, Syabas has NO RIGHT to issue statements relating to water rationing because this will place public in a panic situation.

A panic situation can also spike water usage as consumers tend to store more water at home.

Section 54 and 56 of Water Services Industry Act (WSIA) clearly specified the requirements for a rationing and powers vested on Span and the minister.

Awer urges Span to audit the data claimed by Syabas to establish a real situation in the affected water supply zones.

Results of the audit must also be made public to explain the real situation.

We also urge Span to publish a guideline to water operators to ensure proper procedures are followed before any announcement can be made.

Langat 2 water treatment plant

WSIA does not allow new concession agreements for water services industry beginning 1st January 2008.

WSIA also requires water services licensees to submit a 30 year business plan which will be used as a baseline for tariff setting process.

In view of this, Span must ensure the following is implemented to ensure the Langat 2 project is implemented transparently:

(i) Quality based raw water tariff agreement must be signed between Selangor, Pahang and Span;

(ii) Pahang state government must permanently gazette the primary and secondary water catchment areas that will supply raw water via Pahang-Selangor raw water transfer project;

(iii) Open tender of Langat 2 water treatment plant must be announced.

Independent audit firms can be appointed by Pengurusan Aset Air Berhad (PAAB) to ensure transparency of this process to ensure construction cost is capped.

Information of the bidders must be uploaded to Span's and PAAB's website to prevent "selective" open bidding;

(iv) Based on 30 years business plan details, Point (i) and Point (iii), impact to tariff can be estimated.

Therefore, there will be no room for build first and discuss tariff later situation.

This is against the WSIA model.

Syabas's claim on NO Capex

Capex (capital expenditure) approval is dependent on the State Government and Span.

As a concession holder that refuses to restructure, capex can be directly implemented via open tender by PAAB since WSIA is enforced beginning Jan 1, 2008.

Syabas's primary job is to supply water and not to carry out capex. The WSIA model does not allow water services licensees to be burdened with capex works.

So, why whine?

Members of public and businesses are not worried who supplies water. They are worried whether there is water supply or not.

We hope all parties be mature and professional in handling this issue.

Awer did publish and mail a copy of 'National Water Services Industry Restructuring - The truth' report to all state assemblypersons and members of Parliament.

Please read it before commenting on the WSIA model!

Water for life. Water is not political investment.


PIARAPAKARAN S is president of the Association of Water and Energy Research Malaysia (Awer).

Share this story