Legal experts have disagreed with the Malaysian Anti-Corruption Commission's (MACC) assessment that some laws should be amended before it can be more effective in nabbing top corrupt politicians.


 On Wednesday, Kubang Kerian MP Salahuddin Ayub revealed that the MACC had told the special committee on corruption was hampered by
 
 <a href="http://www.malaysiakini.com/news/210611" target="_blank">
 "archaic provisions"
 </a>
 
 in existing laws.


 <img align="left" alt="NONE" height="217" src="http://mk-cdn.mkini.net/391/9e92f6cf161352ea5b1ad2916cf6fbb7.jpg" width="200"/>
 Salahuddin (
 
 left
 
 ) had cited a case raised by the MACC to the committee in which a wealthy state leader could not be prosecuted because of flaws in the law, despite six investigation papers being opened on the said individual.


 Among others, Salahuddin said that the MACC had told the committee that it wanted section 23 and 50 (see below) of the Malaysia Anti-Corruption Commission Act 2009 amended.


 Meanwhile senior lawyer Baljit Singh Sidhu, who also teaches law, disagreed with MACC on the need for amendments in the two sections.


 "In fact, section 23 is taken from, and similar to, the Hong Kong law. Hence, I do not understand why the MACC is claiming the law is archaic, whereas it had only been recently legislated (three years ago).


 "Furthermore, you have previous laws like the Anti Corruption Act, the Prevention of Corruption Act 1997, the provisions under the Penal Code and the Emergency Order and the MACC Act. What other legislation does the MACC further need?" he told
 
 Malaysiakini
 
 .


 
 


 
 Archaic methods, not laws, the problem
 


 <img align="right" alt="Lawyer Baljit Singh Sidhu" height="257" src="http://mk-cdn.mkini.net/518/90c5edb0ee9fd46288e9212a948753b9.JPG" width="250"/>
 Instead, Baljit (
 
 right
 
 ) proposed that the MACC should improve its investigation efforts and stop relying on confessions to win a case.


 Confessions have not been used in other criminal proceedings and have not been admitted in court as part of the evidence since 2006, he said.


 MPs from both the opposition and the ruling BN have also agreed that it confessions be removed from being used in corruption trials, however this has yet to be implemented, he added.


 "They cannot merely rely on taking statements to gather evidence as there are other means," he said.


 Similarly, senior lawyer CV Prabhakaran said the matter of interpretation of the law should best be left to the courts and the MACC's foremost duty was to charge individuals so long as there is ample evidence.


 Prabhakaran said the section 23, which concerns the use of office in receiving gratification, and section 50, which relates to presumptions in certain offences, were "good laws".


 While voicing sympathy for the MACC's frustrations, he reminded the commission that its predecessor - the Anti-Corruption Commission (ACA) - had managed to obtain convictions against powerful politicians in the past.


 According to him, the ACA had used the Emergency Order to great effect.


 
 
 MACC making excuses
 
 


 On an example of weaknesses in the current law given by Salahuddin - that state cabinet members would not dare to reject a project undertaken by relatives of the menteri besar even if the latter excuses himself from a meeting to decide the matter - Prabhakaran said there were other ways around this problem.


 "The purpose of a person leaving the exco room is that the person should not be seen as influencing the exco decision. If he sits there, then the person will bring an overbearing influence," said the lawyer.


 He added that however if the MACC found that the results of the exco meeting to be doubtful, the entire cabinet could be brought to court and the judge could decide on their innocence.


 <img align="left" alt="NONE" height="220" src="http://mk-cdn.mkini.net/507/2fc8477b22ae423475fae9211e7c3a37.jpg" width="330"/>
 Former MACC advisory panel member Robert Phang (
 
 left
 
 ) said what Salahuddin had brought up were excuses from the anti-corruption body for its inability to reel in the big fish.


 For example, he said
 <a href="http://www.malaysiakini.com/news/210046" target="_blank">
 
 many allegations
 
 </a>
 against attorney-general Abdul Gani Pail and former inspector-general of police Musa Hassan were apparently ignored by MACC, at times on grounds that no report was made against the duo.


 "You and I know that any media report can be considered as a first information report to initiate investigations," he said.


 <hr/>


 MALAYSIAN ANTI-CORRUPTION COMMISSION ACT 2009


 PART IV


 OFFENCES AND PENALTIES


 
 Section 23 - Offence of using office or position for gratification
 


 (1) Any officer of a public body who uses his office or position for any gratification, whether for himself, his relative or associate, commits an offence.


 (2) For the purposes of subsection (1), an officer of a public body shall be presumed, until the contrary is proved, to use his office or position for any gratification, whether for himself, his relative or associate, when he makes any decision, or takes any action, in relation to any matter in which such officer, or any relative or associate of his, has an interest, whether directly or indirectly.


 (3) For the avoidance of doubt, it is declared that, for the purposes of subsection (1), any member of the administration of a State shall be deemed to use his office or position for gratification when he acts contrary to subsection 2(8) of the Eighth Schedule to the Federal Constitution or the equivalent provision in the Constitution or Laws of the Constitution of that State.


 (4) This section shall not apply to an officer who holds office in a public body as a representative of another public body which has the control or partial control over the first-mentioned public body in respect of any matter or thing done in his capacity as such representative for the interest or advantage of that other public body.


 PART VI


 EVIDENCE


 
 Section 50 - Presumption in certain offences
 


 (1) Where in any proceedings against any person for an offence under section 16, 17, 18, 20, 21, 22 or 23 it is proved that any gratification has been received or agreed to be received, accepted or agreed to be accepted, obtained or attempted to be obtained, solicited, given or agreed to be given, promised, or offered, by or to the accused, the gratification shall be presumed to have been corruptly received or agreed to be received, accepted or agreed to be accepted, obtained or attempted to be obtained, solicited, given or agreed to be given, promised, or offered as an inducement or a reward for or on account of the matters set out in the particulars of the offence, unless the contrary is proved.


 (2) Where in any proceedings against any person for an offence under section 161, 162, 163 or 164 of the Penal Code, it is proved that such person has accepted or agreed to accept, or obtained or attempted to obtain any gratification, such person shall be presumed to have done so as a motive or reward for the matters set out in the particulars of the offence, unless thecontrary is proved.


 (3) Where in any proceedings against any person for an offence under section 165 of the Penal Code it is proved that such person has accepted or attempted to obtain any valuable thing without consideration or for a consideration which such person knows to be inadequate, such person shall be presumed to have done so with such knowledge as to the circumstances as set out in the particulars of the offence, unless the contrary is proved.


 (4) Where in any proceedings against any person for an offence under paragraph 137(1)(b) of the Customs Act 1967, it is proved that any officer of customs or other person duly employed forthe prevention of smuggling has accepted, agreed to accept or attempted to obtain any bribe, gratuity, recompense, or reward, such officer or person shall be presumed to have done so for the neglect or non-performance of his duty as set out in the particulars of the offence, unless the contrary is proved.


 
 
 Related stories
 
 


 <a href="http://www.malaysiakini.com/news/210853">
 Taib's son rich from gov't deals, but no proof of abuse
 </a>


 <a href="http://www.malaysiakini.com/news/210866">
 PKR: Gag order on PAC a breach of standing orders
 </a>


 <a href="http://www.malaysiakini.com/news/210817">
 Ling trial: Court allows Kadir impeachment application
 </a>


 <a href="http://www.malaysiakini.com/news/210816">
 Khir Toyo's appeal hearing put off to December
 </a>


 <a href="http://www.malaysiakini.com/news/210815">
 Not shoddy laws, only shoddy MACC
 </a>

UPDATED 6.10PM

Archaic investigation methods and not the laws should be blamed for MACC's failure to reel in the big fish, say lawyers.

Experts: MACC's procedures flawed, not the law

KINI ROUNDUP | Key headlines you may have missed, in brief.

Authorities go after journalists, interviewees and 10 news you may have missed

With PAP’s impressive economic track record and campaign restrictions in force, a total wipeout of the opposition is a real possibility.

Opposition leaders fear clean sweep in Singapore polls

Annuar says he was talking about the current support for Muhyiddin Yassin but can't say about a few years down the road.

Annuar explains 'Muhyiddin for GE15' comment amid internal pushback

He claims BN not only has to share positions with Bersatu but also the G10 comprising supporters of Azmin Ali.

Umno man wants proof that BN is not receiving 'short end of the stick'

The former Bersatu Youth chief says he will withdraw his civil suit against the party over his removal as a Bersatu member.

'You can take it' - Syed Saddiq says won't delay bid to cast him out of Bersatu

'If we are removed, then we will bow out in honour. Be a person with class,' says Nga Kor Ming.

Nga : I will not stay a minute longer if voted out as deputy speaker

Heidy Quah is being investigated for criminal defamation and improper use of network facilities or network service.

'Upsetting and hurtful' - activist on investigation into post on refugee conditions

SPECIAL REPORT | The equipment which assists humans to detect wrongdoings is tangled with an allegation of fraud.

Murky procurement of 'blacklisted' X-ray scanners

The former transport minister said the government is unfairly excluding the Harapan state.

Loke: PN playing partisan politics by realigning ECRL to skip Negeri Sembilan

This comes after an Al Jazeera report on the detention of migrants during the MCO period stirs up controversy.

Health DG justifies detention of migrants amid Al Jazeera row

Harapan commits to earlier decision of Anwar as PM candidate

Dr M's stalwart leaves Amanah, urges Harapan to reject Anwar

Anwar confident Harapan will now refocus on struggle instead of PM candidate

Exodus in Ampang PKR as members follow Zuraida to PN

Indian soldiers unarmed and caught by surprise in China clash, families say

Kelantan water woes to be fully resolved in 30-40 years, says minister

PN could call for snap polls anytime - Azmin

BN retains Chini by a landslide

'Kawan tetap kawan' - Anwar meets Guan Eng amid PM candidate impasse

Two years after resigning, Nurul says will help PKR but no politicking for her

'Why didn't Umno nominate Ku Li as PM candidate?'

Chini win shows BN still accepted by the people, says Zahid

PM: Current gov’t to continue with Harapan’s anti-corruption action plan

Zahid: Umno shouldn't be dragged into PM candidate debate

Nga: Azhar, Azalina nominated as speaker, deputy speaker

Apandi’s claim Mahathir wanted Najib arrested is incorrect - Sri Ram

DAP sacks members who aided defected reps

Ismail Sabri calls for Al Jazeera apology over 'unethical and deceptive' documentary

Come to us, not go after participants - Parlimen Digital organiser tells cops

Summary judgment allowed in RM37.6m tax suit against Najib’s son

Stranded M'sians in Oman losing hope of returning home

YOURSAY | ‘Dr M still playing the race card in 2020’

Alumni calls for action against teacher over victim-blaming remarks

PN faces criticism over choice of Shabudin as deputy minister

'Complete undersea tunnel project probe, explain AGC's decision within reasonable time'

'Despite PN's confidence, its fortunes are tied to last-minute Umno-PAS moves'

Bersih chairperson under investigation over Sheraton Move protests

YOURSAY | Are the PM's shoes too big for Shafie Apdal?

Snap election: Harapan state govts won't dissolve before expiry of term

Transport minister: Proposal to revert ECRL alignment came from Pahang MB

May 18 single-day Parliament sitting valid - PM responds to legal challenge

PKR to unveil new women’s wing heads after chief sacked, deputy defects

COMMENT | Can PKR's 'shadow cabinet' work?

Tasek Gelugor MP appointed as deputy minister in PM’s Dept

YOURSAY | PN photo op - a picture tells a thousand words

Foreign workers in PJ market ponder their fate in M'sia

PR firms still being paid millions for services to Jho Low

Batu Caves under threat as land clearing begins in 'no development' zone

US looking at banning Chinese social media apps, including TikTok - Pompeo

Fog lamps, ice blue lights pose danger to road users - Bukit Aman

Traditional Chinese Medicine Tourism & Health Care Base Rising In North China's Taihang Mountains

COMMENT | Why Umno may want Muhyiddin as their PM

Dr M: Duties and responsibilities of political secretary must be clear

Experts: MACC's procedures flawed, not the law

Share this story

ABOUT

DIGITAL NETWORK

TERMS OF USE

GENERAL LINE

SUBSCRIPTION / TECH SUPPORT

EDITORIAL

LOCATION

RSS FEEDS

DAILY NEWS DIGEST