Malaysiakini News

Ministry’s take on St Thomas school name change doesn't hold up

Ramkarpal Singh  |  Published:  |  Modified:

MP SPEAKS | The explanation by Deputy Education Minister P Kamalanathan behind the change of the name of the St Thomas schools in Kuantan is contrary to what was previously reported to be the official reason of same, and as such, capable of leading to further speculation on the matter.

According to Kamalanathan, the land on which the St Thomas secondary school was located was returned to its owner, a church, after which, “it put an end to the school.” The said deputy minister is further quoted as saying, “the name St Thomas ceased the day the church took back the land.”

The above explanation is quite different from the explanation offered by Pahang health, human resources and special functions committee chairperson Norol Azali Sulaiman, who was reported as saying that the name St Thomas was “no longer suitable” and will be changed once the said schools are relocated to a new building.

Kamalanathan’s explanation seems to suggest that the St Thomas schools have ceased to exist, whereas Norol’s explanation suggests that the said schools are merely being relocated.

An obvious question which arises is: how is a school “put to an end” when it is relocated? I am unaware of any legislation which “puts a school to an end” upon relocation.

The premises of the Penang Free School was initially located in Farquhar Street in Penang, but was later relocated to its current premises due to overcrowding. Such relocation did not result in a change of its name.

Similarly, there can be no justification for the change of the name St Thomas merely on account of its relocation. At the end of the day, the government must surely have the discretion of maintaining their names as the schools are government owned.

Furthermore, there is no indication that the church has any objections to the continued use of the name St Thomas (even assuming its consent for the use of such name was required, which is highly doubtful).

In these circumstances, I urge Kamalanathan to explain why the use of the name St Thomas cannot be continued when the said schools are relocated, as his said explanation above, with the greatest of respect, simply does not make sense upon closer scrutiny.

RAMKARPAL SINGH is the Bukit Gelugor MP.

The views expressed here are those of the author/contributor and do not necessarily represent the views of Malaysiakini.

Sign in

Welcome back,

Your subscription expires on

Your subscription will expire soon, kindly renew before

Your subscription is expired
  Click here to renew

You are not subscribed to any subscription package
  Click here to subscribe now

Any questions?
  Email: [email protected]
  Call: +603-777-00000