‘God’, ‘Jesus’ not the same thing in Christianity
A Well-Travelled Christian Feb 27, 07 3:24pm
I refer to Setatanta O'Hailpin's letter Tuhan more appropriate translation for 'God’. He stated that Christian Arabs prefer to use the Arabic version of Jesus, 'Isa'.

Firstly, as a Christian, I can tell you that ‘God’ and ‘Jesus’, while related concepts, are not exactly the same thing in Christianity. Both words are used in the Bible, and it would be inappropriate to translate every occurrence of the word ‘God’ in the original Greek as ‘Jesus’. The Greek words for 'God' and 'Jesus' are different.

All Arab Christians I have ever known refer to God as ‘Allah’. Therefore, it would make complete sense to translate 'God' in the Indonesian Bible as ‘Allah’ as Bahasa Indonesia, just like Bahasa Malaysia, has many Arabic borrowed words. ‘Allah’ is one of them.

This is also consistent with Islam. Time and time again, my Muslim friends assert to me that we Christians worship the same God as they do. This is especially true of Muslims who are serious about their religion who try to persuade me to become a Muslim.

In fact, I have travelled to and lived in many other countries, and it is only in Malaysia (and perhaps Singapore) where the question even arises. No non-Malay Muslim I have ever met has ever denied that Allah is the same God that Jews, Christians and Muslims all worship.

In fact, the only non-Malaysians I have ever met who claim that the Christian God is not the same as Allah are anti-Muslim extremist fundamentalist Christians in the US!

So, in my personal experience, there are only two groups of people who deny that Christians, Jews, and Muslims all worship the same God, who is known in Arabic as Allah, They are certain Malay Muslims in Malaysia and certain anti-Muslim fundamentalist Christians in the US.

SMS News Alerts
Maxis users
- Type "BUY MKINI" and send to "26000" (RM 5.00 per month)
- Type "BUY WMKINI" and send to "26000" (RM 1.50 per week)
Umobile users
- Type "ON NW MKINIENG" and send to "28118" (RM 5.00 per month)
Digi users
- Type "ON MKINI" and send to "2000" (RM 5.00 per month)
Share your views

Got a short comment or two on our reports/articles? Send it over to Vox Populi, a free forum for readers to air their views on Malaysiakini’s news reports, columns, opinions, letters and analyses. Please keep your comments brief and provide a pseudonym if you so wish. Vox Populi differs from Letters to the Editor in that it caters specifically for brief, to the point comments. Do please indicate which report/article you are referring to. Send your Vox Populi comments to: editor@malaysiakini.com

For Maxis, UMobile, Digi users, get sms newsalerts
Download Mobilekini to get the full story on your phone
Subscribe to Daily news digest
Email:
Join 2800+ friends at the Malaysiakini Group Facebook
Follow Malaysiakini's newsfeed on Twitter
Diy Day Banner

Advertise here ( RM15/day )

Advertise here ( RM15/day )

Diy Day Banner