YOURSAY | ‘But you cannot fool the international crowd.’

Suhakam chief: Immigration concerns, human rights need balance

BobbyO: What a hypocrite. Now he is singing a different tune? Why stand in the way or confuse the Malays when Pakatan Harapan was prepared to sign the International Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Racial Discrimination (Icerd) agreement?

Were the Malays informed of the truth that only two Muslim nations have not signed the agreement? All other Muslim nations have already agreed and signed.

Or was it a cynical effort by PAS president Abdul Hadi Awang and you to create confusion and give the then opposition the opportunity to destabilise the Harapan government?

Since you have been rewarded for your contribution, you are now singing a different tune. But as you are representing the nation on the global scale, you cannot fool the international crowd.

Dr Raman Letchumanan: All the right words by Suhakam chairperson Rahmat Mohamad, but let's see some action.

New brooms always sweep clean until one gets on all fours on the floor to scrap out 60 years of well-entrenched scum and dirt.

For a start, set some timeline. In your own words, you know all the solutions. Great. Can you commit during your tenure that you would accomplish the following?

1. Ratify the Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court. Work with the government to put in place the necessary laws.

You cannot say, as it is, our Penal Code does not recognise the four major crimes as criminal. It may be in the matter of wording, but certainly, those are crimes of the most vile ones.

2. Ratify Icerd. This is the most basic of human rights violation. There cannot be any excuse for not ratifying it.

I recognise Article 153 but if one looks at it objectively; it has been shown that Umno and Co have abused it to the core, making the Malay masses as poor as ever and the so-called protectors of race and religion rich beyond belief.

Not only the Malay masses are betrayed, the whole country is in ruins. You cannot protect the people when the house is crumbling.

Read former prime minister Najib Abdul Razak and Umno president Ahmad Zahid Hamidi's court cases and you will understand what I am saying.

Like the chief justice said, if you don't understand, ask, don't talk rubbish.

3. On the management of refugees and illegal workers, as you have acknowledged, the solutions are simple.

We are crying out for cheap labour, yet we have so many able-bodied refugees who cannot work.

This is purely a symptom of corruption among the various enforcement agencies, not a lack of ideas. This is one area where you need to focus on - corruption and abuse of power in our civil service. That is the root cause of all human rights violations.

So, will you take up this challenge or will you just keep talking and find excuses for the inaction during your tenure?

Cogito Ergo Sum: We are xenophobic even within our own country. We treat the minorities as if they are immigrants even though 90 percent have been here for generations.

We have affirmative action plans that favour the majority and quotas that discriminate against the minority.

And after 60 years, we produce the world’s biggest kleptocrats, thieves who steal from orphans, school projects meant for the rural children and navy ships that never appeared.

You treat refugees badly because somewhere in your warped and crooked mind, these refugees are also ‘pendatang’ (refugees) and you fear being displaced. That about sums up your human rights record, internally and externally. You are a colossal failure!

Koel: This is exactly what people feared about this appointment. A government apologist for the worst practices.

Let's have some honesty, Suhakam chairperson Rahmat Mohamad. If you don’t ratify the UN Refugee Convention, they are undocumented persons or illegal immigrants in the eyes of the government and the country.

So people fleeing tragedies and persecution are not recognised as such. And the laws are clear on how this group gets treated.

So stop this fairy tale nonsense about compassion. Your argument is the oldest trick in the book for delaying justice. And as the old saying goes: Justice too long delayed is justice denied!

KSK: Rahmat talks about "benevolence" and he makes suggestions like this one: "A delicate balance needs to be struck between immigration concerns and human rights issues."

One person's human rights have to be "balanced" against another person's "concerns"?

Is it possible that the head of Malaysia's National Human Rights Commission does not understand what fundamental rights are?

The above is a selection of comments posted by Malaysiakini subscribers. Only paying subscribers can post comments. In the past year, Malaysiakinians have posted over 100,000 comments. Join the Malaysiakini community and help set the news agenda. Subscribe now.

These comments are compiled to reflect the views of Malaysiakini subscribers on matters of public interest. Malaysiakini does not intend to represent these views as fact.