Ex-DPP: Community service better than jail for man who stole sardines

A former deputy public prosecutor has questioned the jail sentence handed to a senior citizen who was convicted of stealing sardines, mouthwash, and coffee powder, last week.

Samantha Chong pointed out that there are already provisions in the law that allow for him to be sentenced to community service instead.

She said sentencing him to one month’s jail would be costly for the government and does not commensurate with his offence.

“It costs RM50 a day, per inmate for food, basic necessities, salaries of prison staff, etc.

“In this case 30xRM50= RM1,500.

“There is an alternative punishment under the Offenders Compulsory Attendance Act 1954. Offenders, in this case, undergo community service and keep their job,” she said on X.

Proportionate sentence

Speaking to Malaysiakini, Chong said the case highlights the need for sentencing guidelines in Malaysia.

“The sentence must be proportionate to the gravity of the offence and the offender’s degree of responsibility.

“We need sentencing guidelines like in the UK,” she added.

Sentencing guidelines are needed to ensure punishment given by the court is consistent and take into consideration all relevant mitigating and aggravating factors, she said.

Last week, Jamaluddin Yusof admitted to stealing 10 cans of sardines, four bottles of mouthwash, and two bottles of Nescafe from a convenience store in Parit Raja, Johor, on April 18.

The 64-year-old was charged at the Batu Pahat Magistrate’s Court under Section 380 of the Penal Code, which carries a maximum jail term of 10 years.

The widower had sought for leniency as he was still supporting his children.

Senior citizen lands in jail for stealing sardines, Nescafe

Ex-prisoners vow to use second chance to right wrongs

8 FRU personnel deny illegally possessing Java mouse-deer parts

After conviction quashed, ex-technician charged again

Man escapes gallows for murdering stepson, gets 35 years in jail