Most Read
Most Commented
Read more like this
mk-logo
Columns
When journalists are penalised for doing their job

Producers and editors in television stations have to be careful - very careful. If the contents of video clips which they approve for telecast cause annoyance, they will face the full wrath of the law.

News of the prosecution of KiniTV and Malaysiakini editor-in-chief Steven Gan and chief executive officer Premesh Chandran must have sent shivers down the spines of many who occupy the hot seats in the stations.

KiniTV has been charged under Section 233(1)(a) of the Communications and Multimedia Act (CMA), which criminalises the deliberate and improper use of network facilities for communications that are deemed offensive, false or obscene, among others. The offence is punishable with a fine of up to RM50,000, or imprisonment of up to one year, or both.

Gan and Chandran are said to be culpable under Section 244(1) of the CMA, which holds directors and other senior officers of a company liable for offences committed by the company. This offence also carries the same penalty upon conviction.

But, as an afterthought, it could be concluded that Malaysian television stations have nothing to fear. They seem to be immune from prosecution, despite the fact that their news content and the spin often annoy most right-thinking Malaysians.

From describing politicians, especially from the opposition, as from “senile old man” to “evil forces out to destroy the country”, they have tarred them with a thick brush with total disregard to decorum and respect. They can report and telecast half-truths, hearsay statements and even churn out fodder from the rumour mills. From editing footage to suit their agenda to re-writing history, they have done it all.

However, at the mercy of the laws are news portals and news organisations that have started to use video images to complement their reports. Maintaining an independent stance, they choose to report the news without having an agenda, or taking sides. Their journalists get their news from a slew of sources, including press conferences.

No news organisation can really put a finger on the number of press conferences held every working day. This because not all news organisations are invited and in most cases, government departments, and even the private sector, choose to invite only those who they would term as “friendly” parties.

There have been instances when journalists from certain organisations have been prevented from such conferences. Such intrusions and obstacles are contemptible and must be detested.

At such conferences, you’ll find a variety of journalists. Some prefer to hold their tape recorders near the mouths of the subject and some come unprepared, asking mundane questions. But there is a small breed who know the subject well and come prepared to ask all the right questions.

When subjects, including VVIPs, are put in a spot when asked difficult questions, their faces and body language betray their annoyance, especially so when the cameras are rolling. After the event, their aides would be scurrying around to do damage control.

As a journalist, I had several run-ins and face-offs with ministers, government officials, sports aficionados and even public relations consultants who try and stage-manage press conferences...

Unlocking Article
Unlocking Article
View Comments
ADS