your say 'From the start when Samy insist Palanivel as the sole MIC candidate, he is actually 'killing off' his deputy. Samy knows very well that should Palanivel stand and win, his demise as MIC chief will be hastened.'

 

MIC info chief Kamalanathan picked as compromise

Doc: Let's face it, S Samy Vellu and MIC will inevitably do Umno's bidding whatever Umno's decision. It has happened before, it is happening now with this G Palanivel issue and it will happen again in the future. Whatever Umno demands of MIC, MIC will comply (after a bit of drama first).

After the election, if Pakatan Rakyat wins, Umno will blame the Indians for deserting BN, and MIC will blame Umno for their wrong choice of candidate. After a few weeks, MIC will suck up to Umno and things will return to normal, where Umno is the master and MIC the Umno's minion.

OhMalaysia: Umno is working to see if they can win the Hulu Selangor on its own. If they can, they will be pretty convinced that they would have Malaysians eating out of their palm with their 1Malaysia slogan.

This is a precarious by-election for Malaysia. I hope and pray the Malaysians in Hulu Selangor will prove beyond doubt that Malaysia has earnestly matured and are ready to call a spade a spade and tell Umno to go fly kite.

OMG: If Umno was sure of winning, they would have nominated their own candidate. Umno has "graciously" allowed MIC to be their fall guy and absorb the brunt of any blame for losing this by-election. MIC should recognise it is being used.

Yuvan: If P Kamalanathan had performed well in his task to rebrand the MIC after the party was butchered in the last general elections more than two years ago, he should not have much problem convincing the Indian voters in Hulu Selangor to support him.

But that alone is not enough for him to win the seat. Would he be able to convince the PKR supporters that he is better than Zaid Ibrahim. I doubt very much.

Alphonz: This works out really well for S Samy Vellu on hindsight. If Kamalanathan wins, it's all MIC's effort but if he loses it's all BN's fault, and he can sit back and say, ‘I told you so'. Good move.

Isana: Bravo Samy, your game plan worked. This just goes to show what a shrewd and cunning a politician Samy is. From the start when Samy insist Palanivel as the sole MIC candidate, he is actually 'killing off' his deputy. Samy knows very well that should Palanivel stand and win, his demise as MIC chief will be hastened.

V Mugilan's name was brought up just as an excuse to challenge Palanivel and then present Kamalanathan as the compromise choice. All this are well-thought out and strategically planned by Samy for his own survival. Palanivel, you have been played out big time by your chief.

Govindasamy: This is ‘sandiwara' by Samy Vellu, and directed by DPM. Samy wants (his son) Vel Paari, but he is still not ready to steer the ship due to his age and the baggage he carries.

If Palanivel wins, there is no way Vel Paari can come in. So it's better to put up a drama, propose Palanivel outwardly, but quietly stand by Kamalanathan, prop up and sacrifice Mugilan to heat up the scene, and finally compromise on Kamalanathan. Sorry Palanivel, you have been stabbed.

Jaghannathun: Why is Samy Vellu running here and there to get the approval as to who should be standing for Hulu Selangor? Just leave it to Umno and then quit en bloc and put a candidate of your choice as an Independent.

Samy, you are too old to be running around and the funniest part is that you don't seem to realise that Umno is not interested in your opinion or choice anymore.

Md Imraz Muhammed Ikhbal: Be it Mugilan or Kamalanathan, it is Umno's pick and certainly not MIC's. It was only yesterday that MIC unanimously resolved that they would not allow Umno to interfere into their internal party matters and that they will accept only Palanivel and no one else as the candidate for the by-election.

Will they now stand by what they resolved or will they instead settle for the crumbs Umno throws at them? Senator and deputy minister post or MIC's dignity? Be what may, there isn't much value to the latter anyway.

Gandhi: What happened to all the hype by 30 MIC branches? They are acting the way Samy Vellu has been doing over the last three decades. Samy just wanted to live up like the old days that he's the one to call the shots. But this time he has to kowtow to Umno and lost his usual self-confidence.

This may be his last show of as a tough guy. Both Palanivel and Samy should pack their bags and go home. It's evident now that in the real world Samy can't demand anything from Umno. Since his candidate is not selected, the only thing honourable act he should do is to go.

 

T he above is a selection of comments posted by Malaysiakini subscribers. Only Malaysiakini subscribers can post comments. Over the past six months, Malaysiakinians have posted 50,000 comments. Be part of the Malaysiakini community and help set the news agenda. Subscribe now .