YOURSAY | ‘Whether someone is implicating the PM or not, Sirul’s credibility is doubtful.’

Source: Sirul revealed five who wanted him to implicate PM

Anonymous_40f4: According to the late private investigator P Balasubramaniam’s statutory declaration, deputy superintendent Musa Safri - who was then Prime Minister Najib Razak's aide de camp - informed Bala on the phone that he would be sending two men.

They were former police commando Sirul Azhar Umar and ex-Special Action Force (UTK) officer Azilah Hadri. Both were sent to political analyst Abdul Razak Baginda's house to take away Mongolian national Altantuya Shaariibuu.

The C4 explosives can only be used with the permission of the defence minister. There is no need for anyone to implicate Najib, because he has implicated himself.

Sirul cannot implicate Najib since Sirul and Azilah had only taken instructions from Musa, and not Najib. Even if Sirul implicates Najib, it wouldn’t be the truth because he had no direct access to Najib, only to Musa.

So, why would someone pay Sirul to implicate Najib? Or even pay him to implicate five people at that?

Ericlcc: Sirul still hasn't told us why he killed her, or how he managed to get hold of C4 explosives from the Defence Ministry. It's not like he could just walk into any army camp and get them.

Of course to Sirul, the PM is not involved. Which stupid superior police officer would tell the two bodyguards that the instruction to kill Altantuya was from the then DPM and defence minister?

Granted, Sirul can kill without any reason; but at least explain why a helpless lady had been targeted? Why not simply shoot some gangsters? How, and who, gave Sirul permission to take out the C4?

And finally, the mother of all red flags, how can a convicted murderer just exit the country without raising any suspicion amongst the enforcement agencies?

Odin Tajué: Yes, Sirul, we know who the five are. They are Mr Christian Ity, Mr Chinese Race, Mr Oppo Sition, Mr Jews ben Mossad, and Mr Orang Puteh.

But that is not important. The most important thing is that you were and still are in a confused state of mind; you do not have complete control of your thinking faculty.

That simply means that you have absolutely zero credibility. In simpler words, your word cannot be accepted because it is completely, utterly worthless.

You, Sirul, are as cretinous as the people who are making use of you to put a certain prime suspect in the clear. You are not only wasting your time and energy, but you have also brought even more contempt on yourself.

To all right-minded people who have come to learn of your pathetic, farcical attempts at helping to cover up the most heinous, dastardly crime, you are even more disgusting than vermin that inhabit sewers and cesspools.

Whether you have now come up with five or 500 names would not impress such people - the right-minded ones - simply because your word has no value whatsoever.

All they are interested in is the identity of the person who ordered you to kill Altantuya. Who was the person?

CQ Muar: For someone who could take the life of a helpless, innocent (until proven guilty of any charges), unknown to Sirul, anyone who believes his words has got to be nuts just like him.

I can almost bet my bottom dollar that he was approached, offered fabulous rewards plus freedom over his "certainty" that Najib had no part in the gruesome murder.

May the day come when all these murderers and liars of the worst kind be eventually punished. Being sentenced will be unjustifiable - only life for a life will be appropriate.

DontPlayGod: Enough said. Only Sirul - and the one who gave him the orders - can say who had told him to kill Altantuya.

Why isn't he talking? And furthermore, to whom did he report? Not just anyone could have given him the orders. So this narrows down the suspects, doesn't it?

After all, he and Azilah were Najib's personal bodyguards. Only the person to whom he reports to, can give him orders - or at least give the necessary approval.

Who benefits the most with the removal of Altantuya? Why was Altantuya killed? Methinks the police are not too keen to find out the motive, nor who had given the orders to kill her.

Franco: With so much drama, possible manipulation, and also possibly a pot of gold at the end of the rainbow, anything coming out of Sirul’s mouth cannot be taken as the truth.

Whether someone is implicating the PM or anyone else, the credibility of his confession(s) - if it can be called as one - is very, very doubtful and needs to be taken with a bowl of salt.

Vijay47: Sirul, I am now an avid fan of your TV serial but like all good movies, the plot is somewhat confusing. I mean, what is your raison d'être, what subconscious urgings or fears are you exploring, what sublime truth are you sharing with us?

Taken together, the four episodes screened so far seem to be a pilot for some forthcoming mega movie to be financed by some wily fox or ‘Wolf from Wall Street’.

It can't be a whodunit since we know from the opening credits that the murderer was you. Perhaps a spin-off from ‘Grey's Anatomy’ in view of your recently-acquired expertise in obstetrics & gynaecology?

It cannot be ‘Repentance’ since you have to-date not expressed the least contrition for committing one of the most savage crimes in the country.

Perhaps a rip-off of ‘The Exorcist’ for the countless demons and torments torturing you every moment of your life for being the animal you are. Then again, maybe religion.

Turvy: We now have a convicted killer holding a country hostage to his secret information.

What he should be told in very clear terms is that we are not interested in a conspiracy to topple the government but simply the bare facts that led him to kill a daughter, a woman and a mother. The rest is really bull.

The Observer: Sirul is like many others of his Umno-raised generation. They are forever being used and abused for a pittance without realising it, and being led and drip fed through the nostrils, ready to sell his (changing) story and soul to the highest bidder.

What dignity is there left?

Alfanso: It was all planned, wasn't it? A person sentenced to death can somehow take a flight to Australia and live freely. Who arranged it?

Are Malaysians truly morally degraded as Parti Amanah Negara (Amanah) president Mohamad Sabu says?

Appum: Now, can you all understand why Mat Sabu had to throw his microphone to the ground in exasperation? I can.

The above is a selection of comments posted by Malaysiakini subscribers. Only paying subscribers can post comments. Over the past one year, Malaysiakinians have posted over 100,000 comments. Join the Malaysiakini community and help set the news agenda. Subscribe now .

These comments are compiled to reflect the views of Malaysiakini subscribers on matters of public interest. Malaysiakini does not intend to represent these views as fact.