Law firm ordered to account for money awarded to Felda settlers
The Federal Court has dismissed a law firm’s application to appeal against a court action by a group of Felda settlers for an inquiry to be held on payments made into the law firm’s account.
The three-member bench headed by Justice Zulkefli Ahmad Makinudin dismissed the appellant’s application for leave and ordered costs of RM20,000. The case by the Felda settlers will now proceed in the High Court in Kota Bharu.
The two appellants are lawyer Wan Rohimi Wan Daud and his partner Asmadi Abu Bakar and they have been asked to account for more than RM11.3 million that the firm received on behalf of the settlers.
The Federal Court has dismissed a law firm’s application to appeal against a court action by a group of Felda settlers for an inquiry to be held on payments made into the law firm’s account.
The three-member bench headed by Justice Zulkefli Ahmad Makinudin dismissed the appellant’s application for leave and ordered costs of RM20,000. The case by the Felda settlers will now proceed in the High Court in Kota Bharu.
The two appellants are lawyer Wan Rohimi Wan Daud and his partner Asmadi Abu Bakar and they have been asked to account for more than RM11.3 million that the firm received on behalf of the settlers.
The respondents in the appeal are Abdullah Che Hassan and 270 others, who hail from the Felda Kemahang 3 settlement in Kelantan.
They are part of the 354 Felda Kemahang 3 settlers who had successfully sued the Federal Land Development Authority (Felda) for cheating them by claiming that their palm oil was of a lower grade, with Wan Rohimi’s firm acting for the settlers.
The Federal Court in 2010 ordered Felda to pay the settlers RM7.8 million in damages plus interest, totalling a sum of RM11.3 million.
According to the Court of Appeal’s written judgment that Wan Rohimi (photo) and Asmadi appealed against, the money was paid into their law firm’s trust account.
Out of the RM11.3 million, only RM6.7 million (RM19,000 for each plaintiff in the 2010 case) was paid out, leaving the balance of RM4.5 million plus interest of RM85,589 and costs in the law firm’s possession.
The settlers were supposed to be entitled to RM30,000 each.
Following this, 271 of the settlers filed an application in the High Court in Kota Bharu for an account of the money to be provided, under Order 43 of the Rules of the High Court, and they eventually succeeded in the Court of Appeal.
In its Oct 27, 2015 judgment, the Court of Appeal allowed for an account to be done on the money, as well as a determination of the sum that the plaintiffs were entitled to and for the two lawyers to pay any arrears due to the plaintiffs.
The document stated that Wan Rohimi and Asmadi had claimed that, among others, that the law firm had invoiced each of the plaintiffs in 2010 for a sum of RM15,000 (totalling RM5.3 million), which was subsequently reduced by 15 percent (to RM4.5 million in total). The invoice was not disputed.
However, the Court of Appeal found that the invoice was never served to the plaintiffs.
“Since the invoices were never served, the defendants’ (Wan Rohimi and Asmadi) argument that there was no challenge of the invoices runs hollow as it was impossible for the plaintiffs to challenge the invoices.
“On the above premise, it also follows that the defendants’ argument that they were entitled to deduct the revised legal fees is also a non-starter,” Court of Appeal judge Vernon Ong said in his judgment last year.
The Felda settlers were represented by Mohd Yaacob Bakanali and Azmer Md Saad in today’s hearing, while Yusfarizal Yussoff appeared for Wan Rohimi and Asmadi.
Other members on the bench today were the Federal Court judges Balia Yusof Wahi and Zaharah Ibrahim.
Report this comment


Are you sure you want to delete this comment?
This action cannot be undone.