COMMENT | Comprehensive review of school safety, student well-being needed
COMMENT | We, the members of G25, are deeply disturbed by the series of serious and, in three recent cases, fatal incidents of violence involving school students. In July, a 15-year-old student in Banting was repeatedly stabbed by a schoolmate.
In September, 14-year-old Idlan Fareeq died after allegedly being assaulted by senior students at a school hostel in Kuala Pilah. Most recently, on Oct 3, 16-year-old Irene Sofiya Khairool Faisal was found with serious injuries at a school in Yong Peng and subsequently died.
Just yesterday, on Oct 6, according to an online article by Sinar Harian, a 19-year-old female student in Kuantan was found dead in a rented room. According to the article, the suspected cause of her death was murder.
These incidents within a short period, including three deaths, should compel the government to question why our existing child protection systems are not keeping our children safe.
In October 2025, following the fatal stabbing of 16-year-old Yap Shing Xuen at a school in Bandar Utama that month, the Education Ministry announced additional safety measures for schools, including millions allocated for closed-circuit television (CCTV), stronger police monitoring, full-time assistant hostel wardens and a Child Protection Policy.
Earlier that year, in July 2025...
COMMENT | We, the members of G25, are deeply disturbed by the series of serious and, in three recent cases, fatal incidents of violence involving school students. In July, a 15-year-old student in Banting was repeatedly stabbed by a schoolmate.
In September, 14-year-old Idlan Fareeq died after allegedly being assaulted by senior students at a school hostel in Kuala Pilah. Most recently, on Oct 3, 16-year-old Irene Sofiya Khairool Faisal was found with serious injuries at a school in Yong Peng and subsequently died.
Just yesterday, on Oct 6, according to an online article by Sinar Harian, a 19-year-old female student in Kuantan was found dead in a rented room. According to the article, the suspected cause of her death was murder.
These incidents within a short period, including three deaths, should compel the government to question why our existing child protection systems are not keeping our children safe.
In October 2025, following the fatal stabbing of 16-year-old Yap Shing Xuen at a school in Bandar Utama that month, the Education Ministry announced additional safety measures for schools, including millions allocated for closed-circuit television (CCTV), stronger police monitoring, full-time assistant hostel wardens and a Child Protection Policy.
/file/publisher-c1a3f893382d2b2f8a9aa22a654d9c97/2025/08/36cae4d66f2565aaf643de16c12be6fd.jpg)
Earlier that year, in July 2025, 13-year-old Zara Qairina Mahathir (above), a student in Sabah, died after being found unconscious and critically injured near her school hostel. Her death, amid allegations of bullying, prompted a police investigation, an exhumation and post-mortem, and an inquest.
Repeated tragedies
Yet, almost a year later, tragedy has struck repeatedly. Even more concerning is the fact that these recent incidents of child violence and deaths occurred after the ministry launched its Safe School Management Guidelines and Student Protection Policy on June 11, 2026.
The policy included strengthening the physical, social and emotional safety of students, with prevention, monitoring, reporting, intervention and enforcement as its five key pillars.
Unfortunately, the number of bullying cases remains deeply worrying. In the Dewan Rakyat yesterday, as reported by the New Straits Times, Prime Minister Anwar Ibrahim stated that there have been 5,681 reported bullying cases in schools nationwide between January and August 2026, not including those that go unreported.
It is upsetting to think that child safety is being treated more reactively than proactively despite the preventative policies announced over the years. Counselling teams should not appear only after violence. Safety audits should not be triggered only after a death. CCTV gaps should not become apparent only after a serious incident. Security patrols should not be scrutinised only after a child is found injured or dead.
Prevention must come before tragedy, especially where children are involved, as no solution will ever erase the emotional and physical scars inflicted on the children affected.
/file/publisher-c1a3f893382d2b2f8a9aa22a654d9c97/2023/01/d69e3aeaf75e5a09c46f9efd86f1a3ac.jpg)
We believe the government must also look beyond physical security. CCTV, guards, gates and disciplinary procedures are necessary, but they cannot by themselves address the reasons why some children become deeply distressed, aggressive, isolated or violent.
We must understand the root causes. Our children are growing up in an increasingly pressured environment. Our education system places great emphasis on academic performance, examinations and competition, even though not every child will excel academically.
Children are also more easily exposed to violence online, through entertainment and social media. At the same time, the pressures of the ever-increasing cost of living see both parents working in many households, leaving less time for both parents and children to be at home together. Some children spend more time at school and in transit or tuition centres than at home during the week.
Play, create, explore
Children need more than academic instruction in schools. They need belonging, friendship, purpose, exercise, creativity, confidence and trusted adults whom they can turn to. Schools should therefore not only be places where children can learn, but also where they can play, create, explore and belong, away from heavy academic pressure and online influence.
More sports, music, drama, art, concerts, exhibitions, community activities and outdoor education should not be regarded as distractions from education, but part of a healthy education. As the familiar saying goes, “All work and no play makes Jack a dull boy”.
For children and adolescents, opportunities for healthy recreation and creativity should not be considered luxuries. They can provide a sense of purpose and belonging, relieve pressure and give children positive outlets for their energy and emotions. A child who is disengaged, isolated or without constructive interests may be more vulnerable to distress and unhealthy behaviour, both in school and at home.
/file/publisher-c1a3f893382d2b2f8a9aa22a654d9c97/2022/06/c9eaf917c0e5cca6fb40584e25caec89.jpg)
The government should therefore ensure that such opportunities are available to children in all schools, including schools whose parents cannot afford to finance those types of activities which can be expensive.
Outdoor education and supervised trips to forests, rivers, mountains and other natural environments, for example, give children constructive channels for their energy, strengthen healthy relationships and bonds with their classmates, and expose them to exciting and educational experiences beyond the classroom.
If these are recognised as part of holistic education, the ministry should provide adequate funding rather than leaving schools to depend on private donors.
At the same time, teachers cannot be expected to carry every responsibility. Teachers are already under considerable pressure. Every school should have appropriately trained personnel responsible for student well-being, whose role includes identifying vulnerable students, supporting teachers with difficult situations, following up on warning signs and ensuring that safeguarding procedures and policies are actually being implemented and are working.
Parents too need support. A meaningful national strategy must involve children, parents, teachers, school leaders, counsellors, health professionals and the wider community. We need evidence-based programmes adapted to Malaysia's cultural and social circumstances, rather than repeatedly introducing new measures only when a crisis occurs.
Better data analysis, transparency
We also need much better data analysis and transparency. The government cannot properly address a problem that it cannot or will not measure. In this regard, we commend Anwar for warning schools not to conceal bullying or disciplinary cases to protect their reputation. Information on bullying, violence, self-harm, suicide attempts, suicides, absenteeism, disciplinary cases and other indicators of distress should be systematically collected and analysed, with appropriate safeguards for children's privacy.
/file/publisher-c1a3f893382d2b2f8a9aa22a654d9c97/2022/12/50d7ce66cac16b05810adb28cbf5aeaa.jpg)
Where serious concerns about the mental health and well-being of children and adolescents exist, qualified researchers, clinicians, universities and civil-society organisations should be given appropriate access to the data and, where necessary, to schools.
Independent expertise should be welcomed, not kept at arm's length. An effective solution can only be designed if the experts are given the full picture. Such a complex problem cannot be placed on one ministry alone. The government has a special responsibility to make sure schools are more than places where lessons are conducted, but also places where a child is safe, seen, heard and supported, no matter who gets the credit for the solution and its execution.
G25 therefore calls for an independent, comprehensive review of school safety and student well-being, involving stakeholders and experts, rather than a series of separate reviews following each tragedy that is analysed in silo.
It should examine physical security, hostel supervision, CCTV coverage and maintenance, security patrols, after-school and weekend activities, bullying and disciplinary procedures, mental health support, teacher workload, safeguarding and the effectiveness of existing policies.
Every school should have a practical risk assessment identifying vulnerable locations, activities and times, including hostels, halls, staircases, secluded areas and periods outside normal classroom hours, and these assessments should be reviewed regularly.
We recognise that no system can guarantee that every act of violence will be prevented. However, we are concerned that we will continue to see a reactive approach where action is only taken after a crisis, with the announcement of another measure and review, only to move on until the next tragedy. That is not good enough when we are dealing with the safety and lives of children.
We, the members of G25, call on our leaders to demonstrate that they are prepared to confront this problem with the seriousness, resources and sustained leadership that it requires. We do not need another promise after the next tragedy that “we will do better”. We need action and implementation before the next child is harmed.
G25 is a group of influential Malays advocating moderation, constitutional rights, justice, and good governance in Malaysia.
The views expressed here are those of the author/contributor and do not necessarily represent the views of Malaysiakini.
Ministry of Education should devise strict disciplinary measures to be imposed in all schools. Once the measures are enforced in schools, form teachers who notice unruly and aggressively misbehaving students should send the students to the Principal's Office to be reprimanded. If they persist to misbehave they should be given a warning and their parents should be notified. If they continue to be incorrigible they should be expelled from the schools before they have the chance to commit untoward incidents in order to keep the schools safe.
Steps should certainly be taken to better ensure the security of our children in school. But we should also address the elephant in the room. Politicians who use their pulpit to bully minorities, the availability of social media for people to comment freely and blindly, spewing forth their hated thoughts, all going unpunished, worse; unrebuked, most definitely shape society's perception of what they can or cannot do. When once upon a time, these people dare not voice out their thoughts for fear of being rebuke, now they freely and frequently indulge in hate speech, knowing that there is no repercussion. The more they spew, the more arrogant they become. Meanwhile, our children see, hear absorb and emulate. Bullying becomes the norm and sometimes, this turns physical. We are now reaping the seeds sown.
Education of the whole person emphasises physical, mental, emotional and social nurturing. Not just the intellect. How are schools putting this into practice? In developed countries, education depts are recognising the detrimental effects of online and internet activities. They are minimising these and requiring students to acquire healthy habits and ways of learning. There is much literature on this that cannot be covered in a small space here. We have some of this concepts in programmes like STPM which requires student involvement in sports, uniformed activities and such. This used to be a norm in schools as well decades back. If such habits and coping strategies are not inculcated early in children and teenagers, we get unmanageable delinquents by the time they hit their early teens. Unfortunately, today schools are being built without facilities for sports and for proper physical devpt. Some school use PE periods to get students to cram. There is no balance to the learning. Much of this probably points at poorly developed, outdated curricula and weak assessments that has failed to keep up with changes around us. Teacher training that harkens back to a period before these modern day stresses and distractions arrived needs to be addressed. Why are education officers not seeking help from successful neighbouring countries? All this can now be done through videoconferencing without spending large amounts on meaningless trips down the Nile or to see the Statue of Liberty. Get help. Set clear standards of achievement (non-negotiable) and educate the whole person. Of course, the family and the home also play an important part in all this. And they need to be held to account if they fail.
Report this comment
/file/publisher-c1a3f893382d2b2f8a9aa22a654d9c97/2022/10/111b24d0011efe89e39b9482d3b223c8.jpg)

/file/publisher-c1a3f893382d2b2f8a9aa22a654d9c97/2024/09/051a26f69fc289398b827737b67d5a58.jpg)
/file/attachments/orphans/MPfromParlitoday-AhmadYunusHairi1_648809.png)
/file/attachments/orphans/46545645645_278163.png)
/file/publisher-c1a3f893382d2b2f8a9aa22a654d9c97/2020/01/a2b2a1fd1a86cfc5d0f980ae21fe6ce5.jpg)
/file/attachments/orphans/legalinsanity_341398.png)
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?
This action cannot be undone.